In 2024, the scholarly publishing industry is embracing a shift in the way research is conducted, written, and reviewed. The driving force behind this shift? A surge in technology and a stronger push for open access. Artificial intelligence (AI) is starting to play a big role in elevating publishing workflows and processes. At the same time, open access models are evolving, providing more ways for researchers to share their findings with the world.
This blog unpacks these industry trends, exploring how they’re set to transform scholarly publishing. We’ll look at the opportunities and challenges ahead, aiming to understand how these advancements could make research more accessible and collaborative than ever before. Let’s begin.
AI-powered Research and Review
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) into scholarly communication has touched everything from the inception of research ideas to the peer review process. Tools like generative AI and large language models are changing the game, potentially speeding up the traditionally slow peer review process.
Generative AI and large language models, for instance, are being utilized to automate the initial stages of manuscript screening, identifying potential issues with formatting, plagiarism, or even basic research integrity before human review.
Further, AI applications such as SciScore and Proofig aid in the methodological and image verification during peer review, enhancing the accuracy and reliability of published research. These AI advancements not only expedite the review process but also enrich the research and drafting phases, making them more efficient and less prone to human error.
For publishers and researchers, the rise of AI offers exciting possibilities. AI can streamline submission and review processes through automated systems that can instantly check for submission completeness, adherence to guidelines, and even predict potential peer reviewers based on manuscript content. For example, automated systems like Penelope.ai perform initial manuscript checks, ensuring submissions meet the journal’s guidelines before entering the peer review stage. This automation reduces the manual workload on editors and accelerates the manuscript’s progression to review.
Similarly, AI-based services for identifying suitable reviewers can significantly shorten the peer review timeline, matching manuscripts with potential reviewers based on expertise and previous publication history.
AI also brings innovative tools for content recommendation and data analysis, delivering personalized research suggestions based on previous readings and citations. For instance, Scite.ai’s citation analysis tool not only categorizes content but also evaluates the supporting or contrasting nature of citations within a paper, providing deeper insights into the cited work’s relevance and reliability. This level of personalized and nuanced analysis helps researchers uncover new relationships between studies, identify emerging trends, and find previously overlooked research, thereby broadening the scope of their work.
Open Access Evolves: Beyond the Gold Standard
Open Access (OA) is evolving, transitioning from the traditional Gold OA model to embrace more diverse approaches like diamond and platinum OA. Gold OA typically involves authors publishing in open access journals, where articles are immediately available to readers without a paywall, often requiring the author to pay an Article Processing Charge (APC).
Diamond OA, on the other hand, offers a similar immediate access but without charging authors any APCs, often supported by institutions or scholarly societies. Platinum OA also provides free access to articles without charging APCs, relying on funding models that cover operational costs through means other than direct payments from authors.
These emerging models offer researchers and institutions more control and introduce alternative funding mechanisms, challenging the publisher-centric norms of academic publishing.
This evolution requires publishers to adapt by developing more flexible publishing options that reflect a commitment to accessibility and authorship control:
Green Open Access, or “repository-based open access”, where authors publish in subscription journals and simultaneously deposit a version of the work in an institutional or subject-specific repository. This model supports wider dissemination without additional costs to authors and is endorsed by funding bodies like NHMRC & ARC.
Hybrid Open Access offers a blend of traditional and OA publishing. If an Article Processing Charge (APC) is paid, the article is available both through the subscription journal and open access. Without the APC, access is restricted to subscribers, providing a flexible approach for authors navigating between open and traditional access.
These alternatives emphasize the publishing industry’s shift towards more democratic access models. Green Open Access allows for the broader dissemination of research through institutional repositories, making it a valuable option for researchers seeking to meet funding mandates without incurring costs. Hybrid Open Access, while maintaining subscription models, offers an avenue for authors to make individual articles openly accessible, broadening their reach.
The move towards a more nuanced approach to OA is significant. Publishers who navigate these changes effectively will not only support the broader dissemination of knowledge but also help create a more inclusive and equitable scholarly communication system. The ongoing evolution of OA models invites the publishing industry to reconsider the meaning of accessibility in academic publishing and to innovate in ways that meet the global research community’s diverse needs.
Micropublication and Snackable Research: Catering to Digital Age Attention Spans
In response to diminishing attention spans and a shift in content consumption habits, the scholarly publishing sector is observing a growing inclination towards micropublication and “snackable” research formats. This trend underscores a move away from traditional, lengthy academic papers to shorter, more digestible pieces of research. Such formats not only facilitate quicker consumption but also allow findings to be shared more rapidly within the academic community and beyond.
Publishers are responding to this shift by developing platforms specifically designed for micropublications and by offering modular content formats that can be easily shared and consumed. For instance, microPublication Biology is an open-access journal that publishes single, validated findings across all life sciences, irrespective of the perceived magnitude of the discovery. This includes novel findings, reproducibility studies, negative results, and observations that might not fit into a broader scientific narrative.
Such platforms offer new avenues for engagement and dissemination, but there would need to be a major shift in how research is reported before this is adopted as a viable publishing method.
Data-Driven Decision Making: Embracing Metrics Beyond Citation Counts
The scholarly publishing industry is increasingly adopting a data-driven approach, where traditional metrics like citation counts are being complemented by alternative indicators of research impact. This shift acknowledges the multifaceted nature of research dissemination and its reach, incorporating metrics such as altmetrics, social media engagement, and the real-world application of findings.
Publishers are leveraging data analytics to not only offer insights into the reach and impact of research but also to refine marketing strategies and content dissemination. By analyzing data beyond citation counts, publishers can identify emerging trends, optimize their offerings, and tailor their strategies to meet the evolving needs of the academic community. This approach enables a more nuanced understanding of research impact, driving strategic decisions that enhance the visibility and accessibility of scholarly work.
Cloud Computing: Enabling Scalable and Collaborative Research
Cloud computing has become an important tool in modern research, offering scalable solutions for data storage and collaborative work. Its capacity to support real-time collaboration across geographical boundaries makes it invaluable for today’s increasingly interconnected scholarly endeavors. Cloud platforms enable researchers, authors, and editors to work together seamlessly, sharing documents and datasets without the constraints of physical location.
Looking ahead, cloud computing can ensure equitable access to research tools and information. By leveraging the cloud, publishers can support diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, ensuring that researchers from all backgrounds have the resources they need to contribute to global knowledge. The flexibility and scalability of cloud services, coupled with their potential to democratize access to research, highlight the critical role of cloud computing in the future of scholarly publishing.
Multi-format and Multimedia Content: Beyond Traditional Publishing
The industry is moving towards multi-format and multimedia content, transcending the limitations of traditional text-based publishing. Publishers are integrating multimedia elements such as video summaries, interactive data visualizations, and even virtual reality (VR) experiences to enrich academic articles and enhance the dissemination of research findings. These innovative formats offer new ways to engage with scholarly content, making complex information more accessible and engaging for a wider audience.
Incorporating multimedia and VR technologies not only improves the comprehensibility and appeal of research but also opens up new avenues for exploration and learning within the academic community. For example, ConfocalVR, a virtual reality platform that allows researchers to visualize and interact with complex structures in a shared virtual space. As publishers develop strategies to integrate these technologies, they are setting new standards for what constitutes scholarly communication.
The move towards multi-format and multimedia content reflects a broader trend in academia and publishing to adapt to the digital age, offering exciting possibilities for the future of research dissemination.
Virtual Reality and Augmented Reality: Transforming Research Consumption
Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented Reality (AR) technologies are already changing the way research is consumed and presented. These technologies offer immersive experiences that can make complex data more understandable and engaging, allowing users to interact with research findings in a three-dimensional space. For instance, VR and AR can bring to life scientific concepts, historical events, and intricate processes, providing a tangible sense of presence and interaction that traditional formats cannot match.
For publishers, the adoption of VR/AR technologies presents both an exciting opportunity and a set of challenges. The potential to offer cutting-edge content discovery and presentation platforms could set a publisher apart in a competitive market.
However, considerations around the cost of development, accessibility issues, and the digital divide must be addressed to ensure broad access and impact. As these technologies continue to mature, publishers will need to explore strategic partnerships and innovative business models to integrate VR/AR effectively into their offerings.
Bottom Line
For stakeholders across the scholarly ecosystem, the call to action is clear: embrace these changes, address the inherent challenges, and leverage the myriad opportunities they present. By doing so, we can ensure a more dynamic, inclusive, and impactful scholarly publishing landscape that not only meets the needs of today’s researchers and readers but also anticipates those of tomorrow.
Share your thoughts , or set a time to chat with our team of experts.
